Peter's Blog

Redefining the Impossible

MSN Desktop Search Evangelism


Google have released their new non-beta desktop search. Since they have given me pagerank 0, here's some spiteful Microsoft Desktop Search Evangelism:

  • New GDS has a plugin API. MDS already has installable filters for extra file types based on established technology: see here and here and especially here. Ok, IFilters are all based on deeply pretentious COM models so I wouldn't want to try writing them. Interesting to see that you can load filters through a win32 API called LoadIFilter. Wonder if this is of any use?
  • MDS can index PDF files by downloading Adobes own plugin.
  • MDS indexes my outlook messages, even though they are stored on an exchange server: can GDS do that?
  • MDS doesn't take copies of the documents it indexes so saves lots of disk space.
  • I do find MSN search useful, especially the taskbar thing. I like the way
    =regedit
    
    launches the registry editor without me having to open the 'run' box or a command prompt. Dunno if GDS can do this.
images/MDSTaskbar.jpg
  • I don't like the way GDS gives results in a web browser: it only gives you the option of opening files it finds: you cannot edit them, copy them or whatever. MDS results are presented in a file explorer, much more useful.

Peter Says:

over 3 years ago

Ok, I tried GDS but it still doesn't tell you which directories it is going to index so I uninstalled it. I just want control, I don't want it indexing and taking cache copies of any old crap it finds.

Peter

Dean Says:

over 3 years ago

Are you saying that MDS only indexs PDFs if you install ifilter or that you can install ifilter and thus override the MS one?

Peter Says:

over 3 years ago

IFilter is Microsoft's mechanism for adding support for new file types to its various products: not just MDS but the naff Windows 2000/XP indexing service and also Windows 2000 server stuff as well (its search engine I guess). If you want to index a new file type you write an IFilter for it.

MDS supports PDF files if you install an IFilter from Adobe. The link is on the MDS site.

I read today that GDS only indexes the first 100k of a file, i.e. the first 10 pages of a word document. I don't know if MDS has the same limitation (don't have word on this pc). Maybe Googles documents are all less than 10 pages so they didn't see a problem.

Peter

Anonymous Says:

over 2 years ago

You can specify which folders GDS indexes through the preferences interface.

Comments are Closed